Ask Jenna: Why Is My Mascara Always Running?

Proper prep, like using an eyelid primer or blotting excess oil, can

The reason is sneakier than you think Many makeup wearers experience smudged mascara by midday, leading to frustration and constant touch-ups. This common beauty issue often appears without warning, even with waterproof formulas. Jenna Rosenstein, beauty editor at Harper's BAZAAR, addresses the surprising root cause behind this persistent problem in her latest advice column. The real culprit behind running mascara is often not the product itself but oily eyelids. Natural oils from the skin break down mascara pigments, causing them to migrate and smudge. Even those with dry skin can experience oil buildup throughout the day, especially in humid conditions or after applying eye cream too close to the lash line.

Breaking News

Anya Taylor‑Joy Debuts Minimalist Paper Jacket in V MagazineBrunello Cucinelli Celebrates 73rd Birthday with Paris Flagship LaunchHold the Trainers—This Smart Flat Shoe Elevates Any Airport OutfitAzelaic Acid Or Tretinoin? Dermatologists Weigh In On The Best Ingredient For Acne, Rosacea and Fine Lines

Proper prep, like using an eyelid primer or blotting excess oil, can significantly improve wear time. How Your Skincare Routine Affects Mascara Performance Applying moisturizer or eye cream too near the lashes creates a barrier that prevents mascara from adhering properly. Jenna recommends waiting at least five minutes after skincare before applying makeup to allow products to fully absorb. She also suggests using a lightweight, oil-free formula on the eyelids to minimize interference. These small adjustments can make a noticeable difference in how long mascara stays put. What If You’ve Tried Everything and It Still Smudges? For those who continue to struggle, Jenna advises evaluating mascara application technique. Pumping the wand in the tube introduces air and dries out the formula, leading to flaking and uneven coating. Instead, she recommends swirling the brush gently inside the tube to load product.

Additionally, curling lashes before mascara application helps lift them away from the eyelid, reducing contact with oils. Frequently Asked Questions Can I use setting spray to stop mascara from running? Yes, a light mist of setting spray over finished makeup can help lock everything in place, but avoid spraying directly on the lashes as it may cause clumping. Is waterproof mascara always the best solution? Not necessarily—waterproof formulas can be harder to remove and may lead to lash breakage if scrubbed aggressively during cleansing. Should I avoid oil-based makeup removers if I have oily lids? Actually, oil-based removers are effective at breaking down mascara without harsh rubbing, which can irritate the delicate eye area.